Cal is taking Donnie’s disappearance badly, and his sister has been asking questions. Pick up beer, collect Lucia and take Cal out fishing to cheer him up. On the boat Jason tells Cal the truth about Donnie. Catch some fish, grill them at Cal’s dock, then head home with Lucia.
Objectives
The game gives these objectives in order:
- Talk to Lucia.
- Go to the liquor store.
- Buy a 6-pack for Cal.
- Wait for Lucia.
- Go to Cal’s.
- Find Cal.
- Speak to Cal.
- Drive the boat.
- Go to the fishing spot.
- Catch a fish.
- Return to Cal’s.
- Grill the fish.
- Return to your house with Lucia.
Recalibration walkthrough
Worried about Cal
Lucia tells Jason that Cal’s sister came by the house. Cal has been out at all hours, acting paranoid and asking about Donnie. Jason thinks Cal just needs some attention and suggests a fishing trip. Go to the liquor store with Lucia, enter and buy a 6-pack for Cal, then wait for Lucia while she picks up her own drinks.




On the drive to Cal’s, Jason admits he fudged the truth about how Donnie died. Lucia says he should be honest with Cal. Go to Cal’s house, find Cal sitting out back and speak to Cal. He is happy to go fishing.



Out on the water
Walk to Cal’s dock and drive the boat. Go to the fishing spot marked out past the islands. Cal spends the trip spinning theories about Donnie faking his death. When you stop, Jason tells Cal the truth. Cal takes it hard, then raises a beer to his friend.




Fishing
Now teach Lucia to fish. Hold the button to pull the rod back and release to cast; hold longer to cast farther. Slowly rotate the stick to attract fish and press the button when you feel a bite. Hold to grip the reel, control the fish while it is struggling, then quickly rotate the stick to reel it in once it tires.




Back at Cal’s dock
Return to Cal’s and pull up at his dock. Wait for Cal, then open the grill and grill the fish, flipping them when Cal tells you. Serve them up. Over dinner the talk turns to Brian winding down his business and what everyone will do for money now. Cal says he isn’t hungry and goes for a walk.




Follow Lucia out to the car and return to your house with Lucia. On the drive she tells Jason that Brian’s jobs were always beneath him and that he should aim higher.



After the mission
Mattia’s job is back on, so Tourist Trap follows. It starts a run of story missions that runs through to the end of the chapter, so finish anything else you want to do in the Keys first.

Part of Chapter 1: Just Like Paradise in the story walkthrough.

















