Jason and Lucia take the statue to an antique store in Capri to find out what it is. The owner, Evelyn Andrews, wants nothing to do with it, but a British dealer called Benedict Halifax offers to look at it off the books. Things get complicated, and it ends with a chase across water and land to get the statue back.
Objectives
The game gives these objectives in order:
- Go to the antique store in Capri.
- Meet Evelyn and Halifax.
- Break into Evelyn Andrews Antiques.
- Search for Halifax at the motel.
- Go to Maryam’s house.
- Chase Halifax.
- Deal with Halifax.
Dubious Provenance walkthrough
Capri
Drive to Capri in the far west of the map, or book a RydeMe if you would rather not make the trip yourself. Try the front door of the antique store and you are taken upstairs automatically.
Evelyn and Halifax
Evelyn Andrews refuses to look at the statue and wants you gone. Benedict Halifax, a British antiques dealer, steps in and offers to appraise it off the books. He asks to take the statue and gives you his watch as a guarantee.
Accept his offer. Halifax takes the statue and hands over his watch, a Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose”, which you can wear from Accessories, then Watches, at any wardrobe. Accepting keeps the later parts of his story open. If you decline, you get an optional objective to call him later. Never calling him loses those parts and their rewards, although the main story carries on either way.
An optional objective to explore Capri also shows up. Visiting a shop or leaving town clears it.
Breaking into the store
Wait for Evelyn to leave. You can force the front door, but there is a quieter way in: take the stairs, drop down onto the lower roof and climb in through the window above the air conditioner. Open the door for Jason, then search the desk drawer in the north corner of the room.

The motel
The motel is next door. Talk to the resident outside, who points you to a room upstairs on the west side. Knock on the door. After the scene you decide whether to trust Halifax. Trusting him keeps the last part of his story open.
Maryam’s house
Evelyn gets in touch with the address of a house in the northwest of town. Go back to the store to get it, then head to Maryam’s house.
Chasing Halifax
Halifax runs and gets away on a boat. As Jason, jump on a Seashark and go after him. Get close, hold the button to jump onto his boat, then swim to shore after he crashes it. He steals a golf cart, so grab a bike and keep after him.

Halifax pepper-sprays Jason and drives into Lucia’s car, and the game switches to her. Get out, use focus and shoot him in the leg.
Dealing with Halifax
Walk up to Halifax until he stops trying to run, then call Jason from Lucia’s phone. When Jason arrives you get the statue back and choose whether to shoot Halifax or let him go.
After the mission
A storage container linked to the job holds about $2,500 in jewelry and cash, plus a ’32 Hustler you can keep or sell. The story moves on to Lucia’s family with Mami Knows Best.

Part of Chapter 3 in the story walkthrough.

















