GTA 4 Deal or Revenge Choice

Little Jacob and Niko take cover behind a car

This page covers the outcomes of the Deal or Revenge choice in GTA 4, so it spoils both endings. If you haven’t reached One Last Thing yet, come back later.

Choice made inOne Last Thing
Opens afterThe mission before it, Diamonds Are a Girl’s Best Friend
Counts toward 100%Either one does. You only play one, and the story is worth 60% of the total, see the checklist.
Reward$250,000 from either route, plus the You Won! achievement

The choice

The last story mission sets it up. Jimmy Pegorino calls Niko to a club in Alderney and asks him to carry out a heroin sale with Dimitri Rascalov, for $250,000. Niko doesn’t want to deal with Dimitri. When Pegorino leaves, Niko phones Roman and Kate. Roman says take the money and Kate says don’t do it. After the calls, two icons show up on your map. A green dollar sign is Deal and a red dagger is Revenge. Driving into one of them starts that route.

Niko in a dark suit takes a phone call in a brick-walled apartment with the radar showing icons.
Niko speaks on his phone in front of a large window while the call continues.
ChoiceIconWhat it means
DealDeal iconDo the sale with Dimitri and take the money
RevengeRevenge iconSkip the sale and go after Dimitri

Deal

Dimitri Rascalov

You meet Phil Bell in Tudor and head for the docks in Port Tudor, where the sale is to happen. Dimitri has a trap of his own waiting, so Niko and Phil decide to take the money. You go in over the roof, shoot your way through the warehouse and chase down a thief who runs off with the cash. The mission is If the Price is Right, and it pays $250,000.

An orange Infernus drives under a steel bridge on a Tudor road with a route line on the radar.
Niko fires his SMG through a pipe railing at gunmen on a warehouse floor.

Next comes Mr. & Mrs. Bellic, the wedding. Kate won’t come after Niko told her he took the deal. At the church, something goes badly wrong and Roman does not survive. Jacob steps in to calm Niko down.

The last mission is A Revenger’s Tragedy. Jacob has found Dimitri’s men, and you follow them to an old casino in Alderney. You fight through it, chase Dimitri onto a boat, then into Jacob’s helicopter, and finish it on Happiness Island. It ends with You Won!

Niko and Jacob crouch behind a car with their guns drawn near the old casino.
A black speedboat races across gray water toward the Liberty City skyline under heavy clouds.
A black helicopter banks between skyscrapers under a heavy gray sky.

Revenge

Jimmy Pegorino

You turn on Pegorino and go alone to the ship in East Hook where the heroin is being unloaded. A Dish Served Cold is a short mission. You open the cargo hold and settle things with Dimitri, then leave. Pegorino’s crew falls apart, so Phil and Niko part on good terms.

Niko in a black suit aims a submachine gun from behind crates on the deck of a cargo ship.
Niko in a suit climbs a steel stairway on the side of the ship beside a dock crane.
Niko stands on the dock in a black suit with a phone to his ear, with a cargo ship and a bridge behind him.

At the wedding in Mr. & Mrs. Bellic, Kate comes with you. Pegorino shows up and shoots at the crowd. Kate is the one who is lost.

Niko in a dark suit stands on a sunny patio on a phone call, with a green umbrella and cafe tables behind him.
An orange sports car crosses a steel suspension bridge toward the skyline, with a line of dialogue at the bottom.
A group of men in suits and ties stand on the sidewalk by the church steps as Little Jacob in a gray hoodie looks on.

In Out of Commission, Jacob and Roman find Pegorino’s men. You follow them to the same old casino, chase Pegorino by bike and helicopter, and end it on Happiness Island. It pays $250,000 and gives You Won!

Niko and Little Jacob sit in a car, both staring ahead through the windshield.
Niko steps out of a car beside a hedge, with the objective to find Pegorino inside the old casino.
Niko rides a motorcycle across a sandy shore beside a rocky slope.
A black helicopter flies low over harbor water toward a dock area, with a subtitle about staying close.

What is different after the credits

The city stays open once the credits roll, and the differences are small. In Deal, Roman is gone and Kate is alive. In Revenge, Roman is alive and Kate is gone. That changes who is left to call you and who you can still meet. Late calls differ too: in Deal you hear from Mallorie and Kate, and in Revenge from Patrick McReary and Roman. Both routes bring news that Mallorie is expecting. Missions, weapons and safehouses are the same either way.

Niko takes a night call from Roman on a Liberty City street as Roman says Mallorie is pregnant.
A close view of Kate McReary smiling, with short brown hair and green eyes.
A close view of Mallorie Bardas in glasses and a red top, looking off to one side.

What stays the same for 100%

Almost everything. Both routes pay $250,000, both end with You Won! and the Liberty City Minute and Key To The City achievements can be earned on either. The percentage counts the story whichever you finish, so nothing is lost. Every other item on the checklist is open after either ending. Roman’s friend activities are not needed for 100%, so losing him in Deal costs you nothing, see Friends.

The top left reads 100% Game Completion while the Key To The City achievement appears above Niko on a plaza.
A helipad with a black helicopter and the line about unlimited ammo as the reward for 100% completion.

One quirk: the missions-completed count includes the wedding for either route, so Mr. & Mrs. Bellic adds twice to that stat.

A bride and groom embrace at the altar while a priest looks on.
Wedding guests in suits clap on the street outside the church as confetti falls.

Which one most players pick

Most players go Revenge. Niko has said many times that he will never do business with Dimitri, so Deal feels like a betrayal of him, and it takes Roman from you at the wedding. Revenge keeps the cousins together and ends in a clean fight with the man who wronged Niko. Deal is the one to pick if you want the darker version, or if you simply want to see both.

Niko, Roman and Little Jacob stand together under autumn trees on Happiness Island as Roman says they are done.
Niko, Roman and Little Jacob sit together in a car as Jacob says to follow the man to Pegorino.
Niko stands on a night street facing Phil Bell and asks if he is excited about the deal.

Save advice

Make a manual save before you accept the call in One Last Thing, in a separate slot. You can’t switch routes once you start one, and a save right before the choice is the only way to see the other ending without replaying the whole game. For the 100% run, reach the choice with everything else finished or nearly so, then pick either, because the side content stays open afterward. See Safehouses for where to save.

Niko holds his phone in a station hall as the caller tells him to come to the club in Tudor.
The outside of Niko's Hove Beach safehouse, where you can save